Cream of Portobello Mushroom Soup

Creamy Portobello Mushroom Soup
I first cooked this soup for my friend w who came to visit my place. W is a vegaquarian meaning he only eats vegetables and seafood (something I aspire to become one day) so I was flipping through my cookbooks the night before, looking for a meatless soup recipe. Finally found a recipe for “wild mushroom soup with sage” in the cookbook 500 Soups which I thought looked really delicious. We had this soup together with grilled scallops & large tiger prawns on angel hair pasta (recipe coming up) and Bakerzin blueberry cheesecake (which is 50% off this month). I tweaked the soup recipe based on the ingredients we can find in Singapore (for example, portobello mushrooms instead of wild mushrooms, thickened cream instead of double cream). I’ve always like portobello mushrooms for their deep, earthy flavours and “meaty” texture. The result of the soup is really good. I love the deep flavours of the portobello mushrooms which goes well with the subtle aroma of the white wine. The mushroom bits and cream give the soup a velvety and nice texture. The minute we reached home after sending w back, B asked for the soup again and finished the rest of the pot. Happy is a cook when there are no leftovers ;)

Meatless Deliciousness – Cream of Portobello Mushroom Soup served with Basil Macadamia Pesto on Toast
The soup is creamy and slightly chunky so it is filling on its own. When I re-cooked this, we had it as a meal on its own, served with some basil macadamia pesto (pictured – recipe coming up) on toast. Yummy yummy.
Ingredients
(Serves 4 – 6)- 25g butter
- 3/4 large white/yellow onion, chopped finely
- 2 garlic cloves, peeled and crushed
- 1 tbsp plain flour
- 850ml vegetable/chicken/mushroom stock (see cooking note 1)
- 650g portobello mushrooms, chopped to large chunks
- 5 fresh sage leaves, chopped finely
- 100ml white wine
- 100ml double cream/thickened cream (see cooking note 2)
- sea salt and freshly cracked black pepper
- chopped fresh parsley (for garnishing)Directions
1. Melt butter in large and deep saucepan. And the onions and garlic, and cook over gentle flame till the onions have just started to caramelised (soft, translucent, shrunken). This takes about 4 minutes.
2. Stir in the flour and cook for one minute more, then gradually stir in the stock.
3. Add the mushrooms and bring to the boil. Don’t worry if it seems like a lot of mushrooms, they will shrink considerably when they are cooked.
4. Reduce heat, cover and simmer gently for about 15 minutes, until the mushrooms are tender. Stir in the sage.
5. Remove a couple of ladlefuls of the mushrooms, chop them to small pieces and set aside.
6. Process the remaining soup in a food processor or blender until smooth.
7. Return the soup to the saucepan and stir in the wine & cream and season with salt and pepper to taste.
8. Warm through, without boiling. Ladle into bowls and garnish with chopped mushrooms you reserved in step 5, parsley and a few drops (or swirls) of cream. Serve with toast.
Cooking Notes:
1) I used “Woh Hup” brand of “Concentrated Mushroom Stock” for the stock base by dissolving 1 tsp of stock for every 200ml of water. This stock works really well for this soup and is very convenient.
2) The original recipe calls for double cream, which is something common in UK. However, double cream is quite rare in Singapore (so far, only seen it at Cold Storage Centrepoint) and pretty expensive. I substituted this with thickened cream containing 35% milk fat and it does the job well and is so much cheaper and easier to find at our local supermarkets.
3) Ingredients substitution: You can substitute portobello mushrooms with wild mushrooms. You can also substitute the sage with fresh thyme (1 tsp).

Love my soup bowl? I adore the beautiful, punchi blue colour ;) Bought for S$2 at Daiso Singapore.







{ 56 comments… read them below or add one }
yum…this looks like a great combination of soup and bread!
Ok, this has got to be the most delicious looking soup! I love good mushroom soup (not the canned variety, of course). I adore Daiso too and that bowl is the cutest.
I think a lot of us here love shopping at Daiso, heh…
Wow.. this soup sure look great!!!! I love mushroom soup the most out of all the westen soup… thanks for sharing :)
me too, mushroom soup is one of my fave type of western soup :)
Sounds like a delicious meal! I’m a fan of portobellos too, and your soup looks great.
wiffy, this set of photos is SO nice! :up: Not only does the food look amazing, but the whole color combo and arrangement looks fresh and bursting with color. I think the blue “punchi” bowl has a great deal to play in making this all look so good. ;)
VERY nice!
Yes, I do believe the “punchi” bowl makes all the difference ;)
Thanks girl for your kind comments :)
I’m not a big mushroom fan, but it sure looks lovely. Heh. And macadamia pesto? That sounds awesome. Is that a recipe from here? Did I somehow miss it?
Hi Bob, the pesto will be featured as an upcoming recipe :-)
Love the flavours in this soup and photos like usually… first class! :)
Thanks Margot … you are too kind!
Oh yum, would love to steal the bowl of soup from the screen.
The bowls are adorable! And the soup so rich and flavorful! That pesto sounds so delicious too! :XO:
Wow! Looks very rich and am pretty sure like you said it can be a meal on its own. Nice!
I have always been a big fan of mushroom soup! Have taken to making them with white and brown button mushrooms. I will have to give it a try with portobello mushrooms! One thing about mushroom soup is that it gets very creamy even without using cream. That is how I got away with none on hand the first time I made it and have never included in it my mushroom soup again.
As for the bowl, I totally love this series that I had to obsessively collect almost the entire series minus the cups. I particularly adore the ice cream bowls!! I think we both shop at Daiso a lot ;)
Great photos!!
I love the sound of your button mushrooms soup without cream. It’s definitely more healthy and I agree that it can be really chunky on its own.
The cream in my version gives the soup a better colour in addition to a creamier texture, else the whole soup will look pretty dark as portebello mushrooms are black ;)
I think we both need to check in to “Daiso Anonymous”. But fortunately, this is a happy addiction :D
This looks beautiful! Reminds me of the ones I had at Marche. I love it thick and creamy. Thanks for the recipe!
You’re welcome :) Do try it out and let me know your verdict :)
This is absolutely yummy with some garlic bread. I’m a fan of mushroom, all sorts of fresh mushrooms.
Me too, I eat about all types of mushrooms!
This is definitely awesome. My fav is mushroom soup and I love it homemade. Have been wanting to try to make one my own and your recipe is just the right one for me. I understood it. :P Now I’m drooling….
Me too, have been trying to understand western soup recipes for some time. It’s so different from the Chinese way of boiling soups. U trying the recipe? Let me know your feedback if you try it, hehe
It’s really nice! I cook it for my lunch today and when I was heating it in the microwave, the smell that waft through attracted my colleague and he asked me on the recipe, I’m gonna print your recipe and give it to him to try. This weekend, I will have my guinea pig (boyfriend) to try out this soup too! :lol:
glad u like it! and how sweet of u to pass the recipe to your colleague, much thanks! :) U’re so nice that u try out the recipe yourself first before cooking for your bf, my poor guinea pig at home got to eat a lot of my failed experimental cookings haha
oh wow, that looks so good!
yum yum yum….(mushroom addict)
Creamy earthy yummy…
Oh I love the looks of this!
Mushroom season!!!!!!!!! Your portobello soup is very rich, very good for the cold weather here in Switzerland! 10 degree C or less! I have a gastric flu these 2 days due to a sudden drop of temperature after returning from HK.
Oh dear, I hope you are feeling better now. Do rest more and drink lots of water & vitamin C. Climate change can really mess up one’s immune system.
A classic in my kitchen love it – I’m melting like cheese just seeing :)
Cheers!
Gera
All I can say is WOW. You did a fantastic job! BTW, I also cooked soup for a guest for dinner ;) Coincidence, eh?
I think soups are really great for hosting guests … they are so comforting ;)
I love the thickness of your soup!! Alot of times, mushroom soup is served sooo watery! Yours looks perfect!
Thanks girl. I love my mushroom soup creamy as well :)
amazing how using fresh produce straight from the farm made such a big different!!
hi! u referring to my other post, rustic singapore? Anyway, thanks for your comment :)
Hi,
I :XO: Portobello Mushroom Soup very very muchhh. :P
would like to find out from u, how to prepare the portobello mushroom before start cooking?
tqvm
Hi, you can either clean them by using a damp cloth to dab the surface, or you can rinse them quickly in water.
hi, what is sage in chinese? and is it is sold in supermarkets at the chiller or?
Hi ethan, sorry I am not sure what it is called in Chinese. yes it’s usually sold at the chiller section, where you see lots of western herbs like rosemary, thyme, etc
u mean they are in bottles? not like 1 pack 1 pack of vege?
no not bottles. For fresh, it’s the 1 pack 1 pack type … in the fridge section and usually with the others western herbs such as thyme, oregano etc
the bottles are the dried type
Hi, Can i use ground Sage instead of fresh ones?
If yes, pls let me know the qty. Thank you :)
Hi Kelly, you mean dried sage? Yes you can use those. Usually dried herbs has stronger aroma compared to the fresh ones, so I guess you can start with 1 tsp. Taste the soup and see if you need more. Hope this helps :)
the mushroom soup looks delicious..would like to try it..but due to religious reason, i can’t use white wine..is there any substitue for it???thanks…
Hi aries! I don’t think it’s necessary to substitute the white wine. Just leave it out. In fact, I tried this soup once without the white wine and I liked the taste too :)
Hi Wiffy
1. Can I add white/ brown button mushrooms or use only button mushrooms?
2. Can I use this as recipe to make cream of asparagus soup?
Thanks
hi Irene,
1. Yes I think you can try this recipe with button mushrooms.
2. Not too sure as I’ve never tried before, but I think’s worth a go ;) Maybe you can try the button mushrooms version first and see if you like the taste.
Hey!! Just like to add a note to those who like this and want to try and experiment. I tried this recipe today and things didn’t go so well for me =(( Just like to add perhaps you guys can try blending it for just about 5-10 secs so you’ll get the soup with tiny little chewy chunks of mushroom like in the restaurants instead of creamy soup which i got =( unless of course if you guys like the creamy type. And i felt 100ml of white wine is a tad too strong, perhaps 50-70ml would be great. Other than that, this recipe rocks =)))
Go buy the stuff then we can make and you all can hv it for lunch!
Hi Wiffy,
is it safe to put hot soup into a blender to blend? Pardon my ignorance, I’ve never used a food processor before.
Also in step 8, you mentioned a few drops of cream, is that the thickened cream also?
Thanks!
Hello,
is it possible to cook this from scratch. as in I would like to prepare this without the use of any sort of stock.I want to try make this on Christmas for my family but we are really sensitive to stock. (my dad dislike the taste and my little sister get all red and scratchy, that’s why we always eat home-cooked food D:)
please let me know if there is other alternatives.
THANK YOU !
you can make your own vegetable or chicken stock (check out http://www.noobcook.com/all-recipes/#broth). my friend also told me can make mushroom stock by using mushroom stems, but I have not tried before. I bought organic soup broth at NTUC before, I can’t remember the brand, it costs about S$6.50 per tetra pak and placed with at the organic foods section, it’s quite natural – don’t really have that artificial MSG taste if that’s what your family is sensitive about.
Thank you so much for replying, I’m cooking dinner tonight ;D